Tuesday, December 26, 2017

When I was Nine Christmas was a Fizzle.

The week before Christmas, my Norwegian stepmother Haldis’s sister Lucy arrived from Chicago with her formidable mother. Lucy and Haldis were Valkyrie blonds, tall, slender and haughty. With Lucy came Bestemor, the name means “Grandmother.” Bestemor was a large frightening woman, a savage Brunhilde who ran a fortune telling tea shop in Chicago. She was a dilettante in horoscopes, phrenology, and other skullduggery.

Several things happened that were to cast a pall over my childhood appreciation of Christmas. An occasion for jeering arrived in the mail. My natural mother Ruth had been divorced by my father when I was an infant, but now an unusual thing happened; she had sent me two gifts in the mail. The first was a very large glossy Audubon book of The Birds of North America, and the second gift was a silver cigarette case with her family crest embossed on the lid. The book was beyond the reach of a nine year old. I was too young and accordingly the book disappeared on the family bookshelves. The silver cigarette case provided an occasion for merry mockery for the two Valkyrie sisters. It was immediately taken from me and given to my father who for years used it as a box for cufflinks. What was a nine year old boy to do with a silver box? Besides, memories of Ruth were bad memories and Haldis always referred to Ruth as “The Flood” because all that Ruth left behind, after her divorce from my father, was like the debris left over by a receding tide.

The other thing that happened was that awkward thing about gifts. Like all children I had my own Christmas list, but at the age of nine I already had no expectation that there was a Santa Claus to grant the desires of my heart. Gift giving in our household was to be governed by the Valkyrie sisters; even I sensed that. That year, few days before Christmas, I wandered into the basement and discovered all my brother’s gifts stored away in the empty coal cellar. To my childish eyes the hoard looked like all the things that I would have wanted when I was their age. I hope you understand that it wasn’t envy of my brothers. I was already too big for a little tricycle. Rather than that it was a sharp perception that I was not valued. Christmas morning was humbling. I received a pale pastel shirt and a narrow knit tie with pale pastel stripes that I can still see in my mind’s eye. I was encouraged by the Valkyrie sisters to be a little man; an acceptable little man, and I was yet a little child.

The final blow to Childhood Christmas came a couple of years later when Haldis announced that she was tired of getting up on Christmas morning with excited children. From there on she informed us that we would follow the Norwegian custom of opening gifts on Christmas Eve. That of course made it difficult to attend Christmas Eve services, which from the viewpoint of Haldis was an added bonus. She may have had a point. We were Scottish Presbyterians and I do remember our dour Glasgow Scot’s minister William Black opening the Christmas Sunday service by proclaiming “A broken and a contrite heart, O God, thou wilt not despise;” which also misses the point of Christmas. Not that Mr. Black didn’t also have a point. After all it was a very difficult congregation and must have given him good cause for a broken and contrite heart on more than one occasion.

What is the point? All of those childhood Christmases spinning down through my childhood years were focused on family and gift giving. The often painful family dynamics always overshadowed the transient joy of gift giving. A favorite Christmas record in our household was Yogi Yorgesson singing “I Yust Go Nuts at Christmas.” The last line sticks in my mind, “In the corner the radio was playing, and over the racket as Gabriel Heater was saying, Peace on Earth, Good will to men, and yust then someone slugged Uncle Ben.” In a way, it was funny, and not so funny. Not so funny, because the whole point of Christmas was missing.

            Christmas is for little children. Love and bless the little children you know, and do your best to add to their joy. Too soon they will be adults and look back, with either with longing or sadness, on the business of Christmas. And what about you this Christmas?  Christmas will be a lot easier, and ultimately more joyful, if you keep it in historical perspective. It is all about the birth of the Christ Child.


“And in the same region there were shepherds out in the field, keeping watch over their flock by night. And an angel of the Lord appeared to them, and the glory of the Lord shone around them, and they were filled with fear. And the angel said to them, "Fear not, for behold, I bring you good news of a great joy that will be for all the people. For unto you is born this day in the city of David a Savior, who is Christ the Lord. And this will be a sign for you: you will find a baby wrapped in swaddling cloths and lying in a manger." And suddenly there was with the angel a multitude of the heavenly host praising God and saying, "Glory to God in the highest, and on earth peace among those with whom he is pleased" [Luke 2:8-14]!

Sunday, December 17, 2017

The Mixed Blessing of Christmas

In the early morning when I arise and pray the office of Vigil, I usually pray three to five Psalms depending on their length. This morning from Psalm 88 I prayed, “I am a man who has no strength…I am shut in so that I cannot escape…I am helpless.” That may seem odd to you, especially a week before Christmas, but let me tell you why.

These verses confess a fundamental sense of helplessness that actually describes the true human condition. Humankind suffers the illusion that it has power to do what it will even at the terrible expense of putting other humans to death. The truth is that everybody has to die, even the most powerful who will eventually, like it or not, have to die and pay for their sins.

The United States Declaration of Independence declares that we have an inalienable right to Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness, but I note that the pursuit of happiness is easier for children at Christmas than it is for adults. Most of us adults have discovered the limitation of the pursuit of happiness, and years of mixed blessings have worn the artificial shine off shallow Christmas happiness.

That is one reason why many of us labour to provide Christmas happiness for children, but sometimes memories can be an emotional butt kicker. All us who have had to say good bye to people that we have loved, and to some that we have dreaded. Will the circle be unbroken? Certainly it will. Not everybody goes to heaven, and I and many others have said good bye to an uncle or “an aunt now, alas, no longer whinnying with us”.

True Christmas joy begins with the discovery that even when we are helpless God has become incarnate in human flesh to share the deepest pains in the human soul. Over against anything past memories and experiences have to offer, Christ the Lord stands by us to carry us through. That is why at the birth of Christ we pray,

Almighty God, you have given your only-begotten Son to
take our nature upon him, and to be born [this day] of a pure
virgin: Grant that we, who have been born again and made
your children by adoption and grace, may daily be renewed
by your Holy Spirit; through our Lord Jesus Christ, to whom
with you and the same Spirit be honor and glory, now and

for ever. Amen.

Friday, September 8, 2017

Why Do Faithful Christians Stay in The Episcopal Church?

by The Rev. Canon Dr. Rob Smith

Why Do Faithful Christians Stay in The Episcopal Church?   


            That is quite a different question than, “Why do people stay in the Episcopal Church?”  The fundamental answer is in the call of God to be here in the first place.  Let me state at the outset that no denominational group is pure.  Human beings by virtue of the fall are corrupted and much of what we do is acceptable only under the grace and mercy of God.  We faithful Christians are and will remain a blood washed band.  Any student of history will tell you that there are heresies and problems in every church body; there always has been, there always will be. 

            When I felt the call of God to join the Episcopal Church in the late nineteen sixties all of the present heresies were already flowering with the Episcopal Church.  There is nothing touted in TEC  today that wasn’t already being taught and modeled by the seminary that I graduated from; the Death of God, Situation Ethics, and Saul Alinsky style social reform, and secular sexual ethics, were all part of the ongoing agenda.  Where do you think our current crop of Episcopal Church leaders came from?  But even then the roots of the Episcopal Church sank down through an immense heap of manure into the deep soil and bedrock of church history.

            In the first Epistle of John two fundamental heresies are identified. One is a heresy in the doctrine of Christ; the other is the heresy in praxis, fundamentally the failure of love.  TEC [The Episcopal Church] notably demonstrates the failure in doctrine; and some of those who have fled from TEC in fearfulness demonstrate a failure of praxis.  To read some of their published comments is enough to caution those within TEC, whether faithful Christians, or blatant apostates, that the critics are both incredibly arrogant and loveless. 

Some of those who have fled also have some doctrinal flaws that alarm me; notably an inadequate understanding of the nature of humankind and the possibility of holiness, “there are none righteous, no not one”, not even in the separatist groups. Some of them have succumbed to the heresy of Pelagius who thought that you could acquire holiness by your own efforts. They also frequently betray a failure to understand the doctrine of the Church itself.  What is amazing to me is to see catholic Christians aligned with protestant evangelicals and charismatics although there is no common ground in their view of the nature of the Church and authority. Their current inability to settle the issue of women’s ordination reflects that problem.

            Salvation and holiness are not assured by jumping ship and uniting with two-thirds world dioceses.  I have enough personal experience in Latin America and Africa to know that there are no “pure” churches there either, although I will grant that they are in better doctrinal shape than TEC.  Years ago a fundamentalist American college was slammed for their naïve claim that they were “twenty miles from any known form of sin.”  Little did they know that like those fleeing from TEC, they carried their sin with them.

            Faithful Christians, who have answered the call of God within TEC are grieved and with the psalmist they cry out, “Your servants love her very rubble, and are moved to pity even for her dust (Psalm 102:14 BCP). 

A reality that we face is that in many places faithful Christians and faithful parishes are being driven out of their dioceses, but that is different than fleeing out of a sense of outraged theoretical holiness.  To do so is to betray the fact that you may never have discovered the depths of your own heart.  I’m outraged by the apostasy and blatant immorality of many within TEC but I do not see a viable biblical model for flight.  “Come out from amongst them and be ye pure” refers principally to sharing in the life and sins of the children of the world.  We too may ultimately be driven out of TEC and TEC itself may end up outside of the larger Anglican Communion and separate itself from the faithful dioceses, parishes, and Christians currently within TEC.  To me being driven out is substantially different than fleeing because I think my doctrine and morality is better than what I see within the covenant community of the Church.


            I prefer the model of Moses in Exodus 32:10 when God offered him a way out: “Now therefore let me alone, that my wrath may burn hot against them and I may consume them, in order that I may make a great nation of you.” Moses declined the offer and instead prayed and worked for the transformation of the covenant people of God.  These are the days of the Golden Calf, but too many of our “faithful” leaders, unlike Moses, have deserted in hope that God will make a great nation of them.  Which of the prophets, which of the apostles fled from the sinful churches of New Testament times in order to become a great nation of theoretically pure doctrine and praxis?  Tell me. Which one fled? Why should we?

Sunday, July 23, 2017

Law, Justice, and Mercy on the Orient Express

HERCULE POIROT AND CASSETTI
The classic English mystery writers understand that their readers want justice to be done, and that evil must be punished. How they work it out is another matter. One of my favourite authors is Agatha Christie. She has an obvious concern that justice must be done, but she is also aware that those who administer law, do not always do justice; and when you understand that distinction we have to ask the question, how does mercy enter in? The following summary from Murder on the Orient Express will illustrate the problem. I have drawn this version of the story from the BBC Poirot series on Television.





MURDER IN THE NIGHT

Murder in the night
On the Orient Express,
“Ce n’est rien, Je me suis trompé”.
“It is nothing. I am wrong.”
Or did he say,
“C’etait un cauchemaur?”
“It was a nightmare.”
The nightmare is Ratchett himself,
The baby killer Cassetti.
Mr. Beddoes says of him,
“Put a sewer rat in a suit,
It is still a sewer rat’
Just a rat in a suit.”
Cassetti is perhaps deservedly murdered.

“Bien, Monseiur!”
Sometimes justice is not simple, and
Sometimes the law is not justice,
But how does one decide, and
Just who makes the decision?
Eh bien, la vie est compliquée ,
et est donc la mort.
Ah well, life is complicated
And so is death.

THE STORY STARTS ON THE STREETS OF ISTANBUL

In ‘Stamboul a woman is stoned in the street for adultery.
“Ma foi!” says Poirot, “Justice is often upsetting,
But she has broken the rules.”
The theme of justice and the law has been introduced,
But what of mercy? What of mercy?

On The Orient Express, Cassetti,
The killer of little baby Daisy Armstrong asks
“Do you believe in God, Mister Poirot?”
Cassetti smiles and continues, “I do now. I think that
God is like an extra gun, an extra piece of protection.”

But God is not a hired gun to be summoned at the beck and call
Of the would-be pious like a mercenary mountebank.
And so “the repulsive murderer is repulsively,
And perhaps deservedly, murdered”,
But what of mercy? What of mercy?

The dilemma is owned by Dame Agatha Christie,
and by David Suchet, the inimitable Hercule Poirot.
The law had failed little Daisy Armstrong; but had justice?
And what about the guilty who stabbed Cassetti to death?
How will they continue to live with the issues
Of law, of justice, and the ever illusive quality of mercy,
Which is sometimes so incredibly strained
By the complex relationship of law and justice?

Poirot swallows his pain over the failure of the law
To administer justice and he condemns not,
But walks away fingering his rosary and praying.
“Holy Mary, Mother of God, pray for us sinners,
now and at the hour of our death. Amen.”

And years later in another world

THE OVERNIGHT EXPRESS

In the Railway Station
Oriental sumptuousness,
Travellers and Peddlers.

We travelled once, Diana and I,
From Venice to Zurich
By Overnight Express,
Cabinette, silver service,
And linen tablecloths.
Curried chicken and white rice
And the Alps gliding
Majestically by.

“Mr. Ratchett has been frontally stabbed,
Twelve times.”
But not on our train.

On our train, love,
And precious memories;
Along the canal in Venice
Roasted sparrow and fried sardines,
As the gondolas glide swiftly by.
And in Zurich an Oompah Band
In the hotel basement,
And in a small estaminet
Along the street,
Champignons sur du pain grille.

While Wretched Ratchett
Is Wretchedly murdered
By twelve good men and true.
But that was on another train,
And all the while we walked
Hand in hand
Along the streets of Zurich.

“Put a sewer rat in a suit,
And he is still a sewer rat,”
Says Beddoes reflectively.

Ce n’est rien.
Je me suis trompé, or
C’etait un cauchemaur.
Or does it matter?
Cassetti is dead!
Bien monsieur.
Sometimes justice is not simple,
And sometimes justice is not justice,
But how does one decide,
And who, who decides?


Thursday, July 6, 2017

Giants, Dragons, and Unicorns

I happen to believe in giants, dragons, and unicorns, not because I was born with eyes open to wonder; but because wonder was there clearly to be seen. The true child within, always wiser that the disenchanted adult who has trouble focusing both eyes on the nose before his face, knows the truly real and is not fooled by the dullness of surface appearances. 

How really dull, dull, dull, and uninteresting is the demythologized world of our materialists; even the ones that write strange stuff like science fiction.  I remember some time ago reading Isaac Asimov’s Foundation Series. The first two or three stories were interesting, but in reading them a curious phenomenon began to occur. The time-line was extended out beyond the foreseeable future, but it was two dimensional, flat, with no wonder above and no terror below. Reading it I began to be increasingly claustrophobic.  Eventually I stopped reading.

This middle earth of ours needs a heaven and hell, a God and a devil, to make sense of human experience.  Both heaven and hell extend infinitely in opposite directions although one is eternal and the other perhaps temporal. At the extremes this realm of middle earth is peopled with angels and demons.  One of our bishops observed, “Sometimes experience irresistibly suggests to us the presence of unseen bad companions who can make vivid suggestions to our minds.”  The author of the Epistle to the Hebrews warns, “Do not neglect to show hospitality to strangers, for thereby some have entertained angels unawares” (Hebrews 13:2)

There is a crux where heaven and hell meet.  That crux is the Incarnation of God.

The turning circle of the years had spun
Through the world’s winters in the way men count,
Two hundred and three times, and then
Still thirty more, since Almighty God,
The King of Glory, had been born on this middle-
Earth of ours, light for the faithful
In human form.[i]

If at the extremes this realm of middle earth is peopled with angels and demons what about the middle realm of middle earth?  There are more wights than we with human sight can ken. I hear a loud protest rising.  If we can’t see them they don’t exist! 

There are a lot of things that I have never seen that still exist.  I have never been to the shop of William Moffat, Victualler in Beer Cart Lane in Canterbury, and just because the shop doesn’t exist today doesn’t mean that it never did.  After all I’m told there is a street in Canterbury called Beer Cart Lane and that the old Roman road ran down part of its length.

Of the ruin of ancient Edom we are told, “Thorns shall grow over its strongholds, nettles and thistles in its fortresses.  It shall be the habitation of dragons, and a court of owls. And yelpers shall meet with howlers, the satyr shall cry to his fellows, indeed, there Lilith settles and finds for herself a resting place” (Isaiah 34: 13-14).[ii] 

Demythologized modern translations miss not only the charm of this older version, but also its reality.  If I had not ridden a horse into the strong city of Edom, I could doubt that Edom and it’s strong city existed.


[i] (Burton Raffel, “Elene,” Poems and Prose from the Old English)
[ii] My own rather literal translation

Wednesday, June 21, 2017

Let Me Give You a Different Perspective on Race Relations


I’m a Scottish-Canadian Immigrant. In all of my childhood and youth I never saw anyone of a different race. The French Canadians were enough of a problem; that, and I heard that there was a knife fight at the local Greek restaurant. When I came to the United States I went to college on the north side of Boston. Every now and then we would see someone who was black. My first direct experience with black people was when a friend and I attempted to worship at a black Church in Boston because we heard the music was good. We were stopped at the door and given a doctrinal examination and then told we weren’t welcome. Apparently we weren’t fundamentalist enough.

After college my wife and I went to seminary in New Haven, Connecticut. We lived on Winchester Ave, just one block into the ghetto. This was during the race riots in the 1960s. When I walked down to the corner drug store I discovered that I was the only white person in the store, and I could feel in the marrow of my bones that I wasn’t welcome. At night we would hear gun shots echoing off the walls, and the next morning the news on radio would say, “All was quiet in the ghetto last night.” No, it wasn’t.

Bishop John Burgess
I was ordained by Bishop John Burgess, who was the first black diocesan bishop in the Episcopal Church. His wife Esther was arrested in St. Augustine for participating in a protest against discrimination. We loved Esther. Bishop John would stop periodically at our house to have a cup of tea and chat with my wife Diana. Our home was directly across the street from a house that he and Esther had attempted to rent, but was blocked earlier by a real estate broker and members of my congregation. I never addressed bigotry openly in that congregation, but I didn’t need to. Instead I preached about the love of God. When the time came I hired a Chinese organist who with his wife integrated our congregation. They were loving people and people ended up loving them. Then the Campbells, a well educated black family, moved in. Nobody batted an eye. Next came Dr. Matthews and his wife and family from South Africa, and the congregation was integrated.

One of the highlights was when Bishop John and Esther visited one Sunday. In the coffee hour, our chief bigot in residence, Loretta, a half Native American, half Armenian woman, had dressed in a black outfit with a little French apron and was manning the silver service tea set. Esther, sizing her up, attempted to hire her for a private party. This delighted many of the congregation who had enough of Loretta’s attitudes. When we left to go to Nashville the congregation was integrated.

Bishop John and Esther came to dinner at our house one Sunday after a Confirmation service. Among other guests were some friends from an evangelical college and some of our Irish relatives. The Bishop could sometimes stick his foot in his mouth. Esther would quickly catch on and change the subject. That was one reason why we loved her. The bishop began with a few negative remarks about evangelicals, then started on the Irish saying that the Irish were most bigoted people he knew. The evangelicals and the Irish gathered around the table just smiled and nodded in agreement. Esther was quick on the uptake and asked, “John, did you happen to see the new cross on St. Elizabeth’s?”  Esther and John Burgess came as a team, and they had our affection.

Nashville on the other hand, was another story. During that period of time I had to do a funeral for one of the wealthiest Nashville families. Even though I was the celebrant and the preacher I was a completely invisible man. By then I had enough of Nashville culture to know that is what many Nashville blacks experienced.

One day we stopped at a park with a children’s playground with swings, and Tim who was around four, spent some time laughing and playing with two black boys his age. Checking things out I asked him if he noticed anything different about the boys. He thought for a minute and finally said, “They have curly hair.”

The next story is about an event on a rainy day. Nashville has some very deep ditches, and we were driving along when we saw the lights of a car beaming up out of a ditch. We pulled over and helped an elderly black couple out of the ditch, loaded them into our car and took them to their home, a classic country wooden cabin with rocking chairs on the porch and a washtub hanging on a wall. The cabin was on the backside of a large Plantation, The next day we got a call from the daughter of the Plantation owner saying, “I want to thank you for taking care of our niggers.” The unconscious choice of language was a bit of a shock for us, but you need to hear what it was. The other remark I remember from the black side of the spectrum was, “White people ain’t got no ass,” which is still mostly true.

During that period of time I was the interim priest of an all black congregation near Meharry Medical College. We were the only white people in the congregation; and even with a post-graduate degree I was probably the least educated man in the congregation. One of the elders of the congregation, a doctor, came to our home for dinner. Our four year old son climbed up onto his lap and began to turn the doctor’s hand over several times; one side was a rich brown colour, the other side was pink. Finally my son held his own little pink hand palm side up beside the doctor’s palm and observed, “See! We’re both alike.” That, I think is rather the point.

Diana and Faith Luwilira
Since then we have had six mission trips with our friends in Uganda and one in Nigeria, and in each of these African places we have made and maintained a number of good friends. The exchange of love with these brothers and sisters has deeply enriched our lives. One of the things obviously missing was the complication of American racial tensions. Over the years we have had a number of very warm friendships with our Chinese friends, with African and American Blacks, with Hispanics in Ecuador, and even with our fellow white people. Palms up everyone! We’re all alike.

Today I see another perspective; there is open hostility between some blacks and some white folks, but not between all. The hostility seems to be based on fear rather than on experience. Some of the hostility is trained into people by drum beaters from one side of the colour spectrum to the other, and also drummed into people by the media who make their money off selling air time to big companies.
I don’t actually know any former slave holders, or any former slaves; unless it is my wife’s Irish relatives who came over on the boat as indentured servants and worked for wealthy families. That was in the day of “Irish Need Not Apply.” My own experience of bigotry was being the butt of a number of ribald Scottish jokes, thanks to the English. [Well, that and signs on Caribbean bars that said, “No dogs or sailors allowed”]. Indeed some of my relatives were Scottish Border Reivers who made their living stealing cattle from the English, which after all was an honourable profession. On the other side there is along history of the English violently repressing the Scots.

Border Reivers
My point is this, the past is past. Reparations are nonsense! We are not giving the cattle back to the English. All we Scots want is to be freed from English domination and secede from the United Kingdom; but on the other hand, the first toast at any banquet is the Loyal Toast to the Queen, and most of us actually mean it. Nevertheless, many of us have immigrated legally to the United States and while we treasure our heritage we love pizza, BBQ, the American Flag and the Constitution, and as for the Loyal Toast; we will toast whoever is President regardless of political party or views.

Monday, June 5, 2017

Faded Glory




There is a strong tendency for those of us who have been through the American Charismatic Renewal of the 1970’s and ‘80’s to look back on those days with fervent longing. We take precious moments out of the closet of our memories and gaze fondly on their faded glory. With earnest yearning we desire to recreate the glory of those days in the present time. We look eagerly on the horizon for stories of new movements of the Spirit in other places, longing for their repetition here. We travel miles, even across oceans, hoping to share in a blessing being poured out on some distant place. It is perhaps true that others, having been stung by the excesses of Charismatic Renewal, view it with distaste; while quite a few have never been exposed to its bane or blessing.

I had the privilege of knowing one of the primary catalysts of Charismatic Renewal in the early 1970’s. Dennis Bennett was a beautiful man and the testimony of his personal experience of the Holy Spirit paved the way for much of the movement of the Spirit that was to follow, especially in the mainline churches in the years to come. In one of my early conversations with him, this lover of the Holy Spirit, made the following prophetic remark: “The Charismatic Movement is reliving all of the ancient heresies as though Church History didn’t exist.”

The problem with Charismatic Renewal was not the Holy Spirit or his gifts, but our humanity. One reason why God doesn’t repeat old blessings is because He wants us not only to learn from the old blessings, but also to learn from the mistakes that we wandered into in our enthusiasm. Seasoned men and women of the Spirit learn that not everything they do under the Anointing of the Holy Spirit is actually Anointed! It takes maturity to tell Holy Ghost Fire from Wild Fire. Nevertheless it would be a tremendous mistake to confuse the excesses of human enthusiasm with the essence of God’s work, but some who do not care for the Anointing of the Holy Spirit, dislike that Anointing because they fear surrendering their own control over life and ministry to Lord of Life.

The word “charismatic” is derived from the Greek word “charism,” a New Testament word for a gift of the Holy Spirit. There are approximately 26 charisms or gifts of the Holy Spirit listed in Holy Scripture. Nine gifts in particular are mentioned in I Corinthians. “To one is given through the Spirit the utterance of wisdom, and to another the utterance of knowledge according to the same Spirit,  to another faith by the same Spirit, to another gifts of healing by the one Spirit, to another the working of miracles, to another prophecy, to another the ability to distinguish between spirits, to another various kinds of tongues, to another the interpretation of tongues. All these are empowered by one and the same Spirit, who apportions to each one individually as he wills” [1 Corinthians 12:8-11].

There are many more not listed in Holy Scripture. Cardinal Suenens of Belgium once said, “No charisms, no Church.” He was quite correct. All ministry of the Holy Spirit in and through the Church is carried out by the charisms, the gifts, of the Holy Spirit. The shape of the ministry of the Church and of each parish is determined by the charisms of the Holy Spirit. Where this is no longer true, you have only a dead and lifeless orthodoxy.

The charisms of the Holy Spirit are so evident in the life and ministry of Jesus that His very title “Christ” refers to the Chrism, or Anointing of the gift giving Spirit of God. We ourselves are called “Christians.” The word was originally an insult referring to us as “little anointeds.” We are in a deep sense Charismatic, precisely because we bear the name Christian. That is why at every confirmation the Bishop prays over the new confirmands saying, “By the sealing of your Holy Spirit you have bound us to your service. Renew in these your servants the covenant you made with them at their baptism. Send them forth in the power of that Spirit to perform the service you set before them; through Jesus Christ your Son our Lord.”

God’s exhortation to his people is “Remember not the former things, nor consider the things of old. Behold, I am doing a new thing; now it springs forth, do you not perceive it? I will make a way in the wilderness and rivers in the desert.” We cannot relive the past, but we can be open to a future unfolding of the Charisms and ministry of the Holy Spirit.

The Lord is doing a new thing. It is at once Biblical, Sacramental, and Growing in the Spirit. It is deeply rooted in Scripture, tradition and the theology and history of the Church, and it is a logical continuation of those things that the Church has always believed. It is a new thing in that it is a fresh experience of the Holy Spirit, Who Himself makes all things new. It is not God’s intention that we fondle faded glories, but that we renew His work in this present time by opening our minds and hearts and surrendering to the Lord who breathes new life into His people.

I once asked Bishop William Cox of Oklahoma what happened to Charismatic Renewal, he said in essence that those who had an experience of the Holy Spirit in Charismatic Renewal are now scattered through all the churches enlivening and enriching them. Some have sought balance in the disciplines of the Benedictine Order where balance and stability provide a firm place to stand in the battles of everyday life. It is important to recognize that we are in a state of warfare, and it is important to “take up the strong weapons of obedience” in the context of a balanced, non-compulsive, orderly, Benedictine way of living. As we pray the Daily Office today we pray the Collect for the Day of Pentecost,

Almighty God, on this day you opened the way of eternal life
to every race and nation by the promised gift of your Holy
Spirit: Shed abroad this gift throughout the world by the
preaching of the Gospel, that it may reach to the ends of the
earth; through Jesus Christ our Lord, who lives and reigns
with you, in the unity of the Holy Spirit, one God, for ever
and ever. Amen. [The Book of Common Prayer, p. 227].

Monday, May 15, 2017

Lincoln and Lee on the Terrible Nature of War





  Among the treasures at the Gilcrease Museum in Tulsa is a small but significant collection of memorabilia from the period of the American Civil War that is tucked in among a marvellous selection of Fredrick Remington bronzes and paintings by Charles Russell and Thomas Moran.  Two exhibits side by side are quite striking; one the life mask and hands of Abraham Lincoln, the other a picture of Robert E. Lee accompanied by the following quote from a letter from Lee in 1861 to his sister:

“With all my devotion to the Union and the feeling of loyalty and duty of an American citizen, I have not been able to make up my mind to raise my hands against my relatives, my children, my home.  I have therefore resigned my commission in the Amy, and save in defense of my native state, with the sincere hope that my poor services may never need be needed, I hope I may never be called on to draw my sword. . . “

One of the tragedies of the American Civil War is that it pitted Christian against Christian in one of the most savage conflicts in our history.   Despite Lee’s sincere hope he was inevitably drawn into the conflict, and but for his skill and determination as a military leader the war would likely have been considerably shorter.  The time would come when General Ambrose Burnside would stolidly and stupidly send his Union troops in a feckless assault of the Confederate positions on the heights above Fredericksburg.  On December 13th, 1862 Lee made the following remark, “It is well that war is so terrible - otherwise we would grow too fond of it.” 

Lee’s fierce right hand man Stonewall Jackson was a man of ardent faith, and fearless disposition.  Of his sense of security in battle Jackson said, "My religious belief teaches me to feel as safe in battle as in bed.”  Whether or not one agrees with Lee and Jackson, or with Lincoln and Union Leaders like Joshua Chamberlain their faith should be taken seriously.

On the opposite wall at the Gilcrease is a quote from Lincoln at the Philadelphia Sanitary Fair in June of 1864.  A Sanitary Fair raised funds for the medical and practical care of soldiers by auctioning art, curios and memorabilia.  In his speech Lincoln said,

“War at its best, is terrible, and this war of ours, In its magnitude and in its duration is one of the most terrible . . . it has carried mourning to almost every home, until it can almost be said that the ‘heavens are hung in black.’ Yet the war is continues.”

            Individual Christians from time to time find themselves in opposition to each other, but that is the nature of the fallen world in which we live.  Only the very naïve would make the mistake of thinking that the conflicts of the past, of either the American Civil War, or of the past of each person can be fairly evaluated by hind sight.  In the midst of the conflicts of life it is not always so easy.  There is perhaps even a reason for war, as God’s way of teaching his hard hearted people the ways of faith.


Now these are the nations that the LORD left, to test Israel by them, that is, all in Israel who had not experienced all the wars in Canaan.  It was only in order that the generations of the people of Israel might know war, to teach war to those who had not known it before” [Judges 3:1].

Friday, May 5, 2017

Sir Mallow de Mar

Editor’s Note:


The following is one of the lost tales from the recently discovered “Le Déjeuner d’Arthur.” This tale, like “The Quest of Sir Cochon Le Cur Faible” is part of a larger cycle of tales about aspiring knights seeking to join the Knights of the Round Table. Le Déjeuner was originally a collection of oral stories recorded by an unknown French printer that some have identified as Jean Dupré, a contemporary of Caxton whose edition of Le Morte d’Arthur is well known to English readers. Through historical misadventure an early copy of Le Déjeuner was taken by Louis-Joseph de Montcalm to New France where it was eventually translated into Quebecois. Unfortunately the French original was lost, and only the Quebecois version remains today. For those of you unfamiliar with Quebecois as a “language”, Quebecois is to French as Spanglish is to English. Tonton Guillaume Cloche has given us this current translation of Le Déjeuner. Today the only known copy of the work can be found in the Royal Canadian Museum of History in Toronto.


It was early in the season of Pentecost when one came riding to Arthur’s court out of the eastern shires. His colours per bend sinister upon his shield were rich chocolate brown and the purest white. He was a hefty knight and full of hearty cheer at finding a new court and a new lord. The court from which he fled was grown stale and its lord right pale, no leader of worthy knights, a narrow poxy man that by Sir Mallow de Mar’s own account honoured not such knights as bold brave Sir Mallow de Mar.

“My liege lord King Arthur,” says Sir Mallow de Mar, “right glad I am to come to the aid of such a worthy king as thou. Command me, Lord. I am your humble servant, and I will gladly lead any quest and work any work that you desire.”

Right glad was Arthur to hear the bold yet humble words of such a mighty knight. But Merlin stood afar off, watchful, pondering, and Sir Gawain with a thin lipped smile beat softly upon his shield with clenched fist.

One reason why King Arthur was such a noble well loved king was that his heart was open, and glad was he to give right good welcome to those who came in good faith; yet Arthur’s weakness was that always there were some who came for other reasons. No good will come from those who offer themselves to a new king when they harbour evil in their hearts for the liege lord they leave behind. Their compliments are a sweet poison that will soon turn sour. Soon Arthur would be beating upon his own shield with a closed fist.

As Sir Mallow de Mar spoke on with silvered words of praise Arthur suddenly became aware of the soft thud of Gawain’s clenched fist beating upon his shield; then looked from the face of Gawain to that of Merlin. Merlin stood with arms folded across his chest, his eyes fixed on Arthur. Arthur continued to smile, but took a step backward away from Sir Mallow de Mar who eagerly pressed forward.

At last Arthur spoke, “There are but two empty seats at the Table Round. One has been prophesied of old. The other may be filled only by one who has won worship through a noble quest. Welcome good guest, but abide and wait for a worthy quest to arise.”

The word’s were neither approval or rejection, just words of courtesy, and though Sir Mallow de Mar answered Arthur’s smile with a smile of his own, his eyes belied his smile and his fair words. Soon he would mount his palfrey and move on seeking entrance at the court of some more worthy king, and complaining all the while of the inhospitable nature of King Arthur who failed to recognize the great gifts Sir Mallow de Mar had offered to the Table Round.