Wednesday, June 21, 2017

Let Me Give You a Different Perspective on Race Relations


I’m a Scottish-Canadian Immigrant. In all of my childhood and youth I never saw anyone of a different race. The French Canadians were enough of a problem; that, and I heard that there was a knife fight at the local Greek restaurant. When I came to the United States I went to college on the north side of Boston. Every now and then we would see someone who was black. My first direct experience with black people was when a friend and I attempted to worship at a black Church in Boston because we heard the music was good. We were stopped at the door and given a doctrinal examination and then told we weren’t welcome. Apparently we weren’t fundamentalist enough.

After college my wife and I went to seminary in New Haven, Connecticut. We lived on Winchester Ave, just one block into the ghetto. This was during the race riots in the 1960s. When I walked down to the corner drug store I discovered that I was the only white person in the store, and I could feel in the marrow of my bones that I wasn’t welcome. At night we would hear gun shots echoing off the walls, and the next morning the news on radio would say, “All was quiet in the ghetto last night.” No, it wasn’t.

Bishop John Burgess
I was ordained by Bishop John Burgess, who was the first black diocesan bishop in the Episcopal Church. His wife Esther was arrested in St. Augustine for participating in a protest against discrimination. We loved Esther. Bishop John would stop periodically at our house to have a cup of tea and chat with my wife Diana. Our home was directly across the street from a house that he and Esther had attempted to rent, but was blocked earlier by a real estate broker and members of my congregation. I never addressed bigotry openly in that congregation, but I didn’t need to. Instead I preached about the love of God. When the time came I hired a Chinese organist who with his wife integrated our congregation. They were loving people and people ended up loving them. Then the Campbells, a well educated black family, moved in. Nobody batted an eye. Next came Dr. Matthews and his wife and family from South Africa, and the congregation was integrated.

One of the highlights was when Bishop John and Esther visited one Sunday. In the coffee hour, our chief bigot in residence, Loretta, a half Native American, half Armenian woman, had dressed in a black outfit with a little French apron and was manning the silver service tea set. Esther, sizing her up, attempted to hire her for a private party. This delighted many of the congregation who had enough of Loretta’s attitudes. When we left to go to Nashville the congregation was integrated.

Bishop John and Esther came to dinner at our house one Sunday after a Confirmation service. Among other guests were some friends from an evangelical college and some of our Irish relatives. The Bishop could sometimes stick his foot in his mouth. Esther would quickly catch on and change the subject. That was one reason why we loved her. The bishop began with a few negative remarks about evangelicals, then started on the Irish saying that the Irish were most bigoted people he knew. The evangelicals and the Irish gathered around the table just smiled and nodded in agreement. Esther was quick on the uptake and asked, “John, did you happen to see the new cross on St. Elizabeth’s?”  Esther and John Burgess came as a team, and they had our affection.

Nashville on the other hand, was another story. During that period of time I had to do a funeral for one of the wealthiest Nashville families. Even though I was the celebrant and the preacher I was a completely invisible man. By then I had enough of Nashville culture to know that is what many Nashville blacks experienced.

One day we stopped at a park with a children’s playground with swings, and Tim who was around four, spent some time laughing and playing with two black boys his age. Checking things out I asked him if he noticed anything different about the boys. He thought for a minute and finally said, “They have curly hair.”

The next story is about an event on a rainy day. Nashville has some very deep ditches, and we were driving along when we saw the lights of a car beaming up out of a ditch. We pulled over and helped an elderly black couple out of the ditch, loaded them into our car and took them to their home, a classic country wooden cabin with rocking chairs on the porch and a washtub hanging on a wall. The cabin was on the backside of a large Plantation, The next day we got a call from the daughter of the Plantation owner saying, “I want to thank you for taking care of our niggers.” The unconscious choice of language was a bit of a shock for us, but you need to hear what it was. The other remark I remember from the black side of the spectrum was, “White people ain’t got no ass,” which is still mostly true.

During that period of time I was the interim priest of an all black congregation near Meharry Medical College. We were the only white people in the congregation; and even with a post-graduate degree I was probably the least educated man in the congregation. One of the elders of the congregation, a doctor, came to our home for dinner. Our four year old son climbed up onto his lap and began to turn the doctor’s hand over several times; one side was a rich brown colour, the other side was pink. Finally my son held his own little pink hand palm side up beside the doctor’s palm and observed, “See! We’re both alike.” That, I think is rather the point.

Diana and Faith Luwilira
Since then we have had six mission trips with our friends in Uganda and one in Nigeria, and in each of these African places we have made and maintained a number of good friends. The exchange of love with these brothers and sisters has deeply enriched our lives. One of the things obviously missing was the complication of American racial tensions. Over the years we have had a number of very warm friendships with our Chinese friends, with African and American Blacks, with Hispanics in Ecuador, and even with our fellow white people. Palms up everyone! We’re all alike.

Today I see another perspective; there is open hostility between some blacks and some white folks, but not between all. The hostility seems to be based on fear rather than on experience. Some of the hostility is trained into people by drum beaters from one side of the colour spectrum to the other, and also drummed into people by the media who make their money off selling air time to big companies.
I don’t actually know any former slave holders, or any former slaves; unless it is my wife’s Irish relatives who came over on the boat as indentured servants and worked for wealthy families. That was in the day of “Irish Need Not Apply.” My own experience of bigotry was being the butt of a number of ribald Scottish jokes, thanks to the English. [Well, that and signs on Caribbean bars that said, “No dogs or sailors allowed”]. Indeed some of my relatives were Scottish Border Reivers who made their living stealing cattle from the English, which after all was an honourable profession. On the other side there is along history of the English violently repressing the Scots.

Border Reivers
My point is this, the past is past. Reparations are nonsense! We are not giving the cattle back to the English. All we Scots want is to be freed from English domination and secede from the United Kingdom; but on the other hand, the first toast at any banquet is the Loyal Toast to the Queen, and most of us actually mean it. Nevertheless, many of us have immigrated legally to the United States and while we treasure our heritage we love pizza, BBQ, the American Flag and the Constitution, and as for the Loyal Toast; we will toast whoever is President regardless of political party or views.

No comments:

Post a Comment