by The Rev.
Canon Dr. Rob Smith
That is
quite a different question than, “Why do people stay in the Episcopal
Church?” The fundamental answer is in
the call of God to be here in the first place.
Let me state at the outset that no denominational group is pure. Human beings by virtue of the fall are
corrupted and much of what we do is acceptable only under the grace and mercy
of God. We faithful Christians are and
will remain a blood washed band. Any
student of history will tell you that there are heresies and problems in every
church body; there always has been, there always will be.
When I felt
the call of God to join the Episcopal Church in the late nineteen sixties all
of the present heresies were already flowering with the Episcopal Church. There is nothing touted in TEC today that wasn’t already being taught and
modeled by the seminary that I graduated from; the Death of God, Situation
Ethics, and Saul Alinsky style social reform, and secular sexual ethics, were all
part of the ongoing agenda. Where do you
think our current crop of Episcopal Church leaders came from? But even then the roots of the Episcopal
Church sank down through an immense heap of manure into the deep soil and
bedrock of church history.
In the
first Epistle of John two fundamental heresies are identified. One is a heresy
in the doctrine of Christ; the other is the heresy in praxis, fundamentally the
failure of love. TEC [The Episcopal
Church] notably demonstrates the failure in doctrine; and some of those who
have fled from TEC in fearfulness demonstrate a failure of praxis. To read some of their published comments is
enough to caution those within TEC, whether faithful Christians, or blatant
apostates, that the critics are both incredibly arrogant and loveless.
Some of those who have fled also
have some doctrinal flaws that alarm me; notably an inadequate understanding of
the nature of humankind and the possibility of holiness, “there are none
righteous, no not one”, not even in the separatist groups. Some of them have
succumbed to the heresy of Pelagius who thought that you could acquire holiness
by your own efforts. They also frequently betray a failure to understand the
doctrine of the Church itself. What is
amazing to me is to see catholic Christians aligned with protestant
evangelicals and charismatics although there is no common ground in their view
of the nature of the Church and authority. Their current inability to settle
the issue of women’s ordination reflects that problem.
Salvation
and holiness are not assured by jumping ship and uniting with two-thirds world
dioceses. I have enough personal
experience in Latin America and Africa to know that there are no “pure”
churches there either, although I will grant that they are in better doctrinal
shape than TEC. Years ago a
fundamentalist American college was slammed for their naïve claim that they
were “twenty miles from any known form of sin.”
Little did they know that like those fleeing from TEC, they carried
their sin with them.
Faithful
Christians, who have answered the call of God within TEC are grieved and with
the psalmist they cry out, “Your servants love her very rubble, and are moved
to pity even for her dust (Psalm 102:14 BCP).
A reality that we face is that in
many places faithful Christians and faithful parishes are being driven out of
their dioceses, but that is different than fleeing out of a sense of outraged
theoretical holiness. To do so is to
betray the fact that you may never have discovered the depths of your own
heart. I’m outraged by the apostasy and
blatant immorality of many within TEC but I do not see a viable biblical model
for flight. “Come out from amongst them
and be ye pure” refers principally to sharing in the life and sins of the
children of the world. We too may
ultimately be driven out of TEC and TEC itself may end up outside of the larger
Anglican Communion and separate itself from the faithful dioceses, parishes,
and Christians currently within TEC. To
me being driven out is substantially different than fleeing because I think my
doctrine and morality is better than what I see within the covenant community
of the Church.
I prefer
the model of Moses in Exodus 32:10 when God offered him a way out: “Now
therefore let me alone, that my wrath may burn hot against them and I may
consume them, in order that I may make a great nation of you.” Moses declined
the offer and instead prayed and worked for the transformation of the covenant
people of God. These are the days of the
Golden Calf, but too many of our “faithful” leaders, unlike Moses, have
deserted in hope that God will make a great nation of them. Which of the prophets, which of the apostles
fled from the sinful churches of New Testament times in order to become a great
nation of theoretically pure doctrine and praxis? Tell me. Which one fled? Why should we?
