Saturday, April 29, 2017

ALL THE SHIPS AT SEA

Ever since spending time at sea, I have identified with Psalm 107. Our ship, the HMCS Sioux had the anti-submarine patrol from Newfoundland and the Grand Banks to the Labrador Coast and the Arctic Circle. We were patrolling for Russian submarines. The United States is still patrolling for Russian ships. We sailed in all kinds of weather. Psalm 107 reflects the personal experience of many of us who went down to sea.




Some Went Down to the Sea in Ships

Some went down to the sea in ships,
doing business on the great waters;
they saw the deeds of the LORD,
his wondrous works in the deep.
For he commanded and raised the stormy wind,
which lifted up the waves of the sea. 
They mounted up to heaven;
they went down to the depths;
their courage melted away in their evil plight;
they reeled and staggered like drunken men
and were at their wits' end.
Then they cried to the LORD in their trouble,
and he delivered them from their distress.
He made the storm be still,
and the waves of the sea were hushed.
Then they were glad that the waters were quiet,
and he brought them to their desired haven.
Let them thank the LORD for his steadfast love,
for his wondrous works to the children of men!
Let them extol him in the congregation of the people,
and praise him in the assembly of the elders.
[Psalm 107:23-32]


Monday, April 24, 2017

In Praise of Honour

In Praise of Honour                                      Richard Lovelace, 1618–1658


 To Lucasta, Going To The Wars

Tell me not, Sweet, I am unkind,
That from the nunnery
Of thy chaste breasts, and quiet mind,
To war and arms I fly.

True, a new mistress now I chase,
The first foe in the field;
And with a stronger faith embrace
A sword, a horse, a shield.

Yet this inconstancy is such,
As you too shall adore;
I could not love thee, Dear, so much,
Loved I not honour more.



Sir Richard Lovelace, the Cavalier Poet and his mistress, understood the place of honour as the guiding principle of their lives.  By the time C. S. Lewis writes he observes that honour is not the highest virtue, and indeed it is not; but in our age honour has almost completely disappeared from our contemporary list of values.  More’s the pity!  Honour in itself still remains a virtue even if it must be a vassal to love and truth.

Today when chivalry is an antique virtue only useful for advertising an expensive brand of Scotch Whiskey, honour and chivalry have vanished from modern consciousness only to emerge in a banal parody in recreated medieval Renaissance games where appallingly costumed youth and would be youth whale away at each other with wooden swords and shields.  One good stroke of the sharp steel of an ancient claymore would sweep away such ephemeral wisps of pseudo-honour and cleanse the landscape.

Honour must never pass away.  Honour at its heart means doing the right thing, doing it the right way, and doing it for the sake of love and truth. Honour is closely aligned with mishpat, Old Testament justice.  C. S. Lewis tells us that “justice . . . is the old name for ‘fairness’; it includes honesty, give and take, truthfulness, keeping promises, and all that side of life” (Mere Christianity, Chapter 12).  Honour and integrity go hand in hand.  “I will live with integrity” (Psalm 26:11 BCP), and I will live honourably are parallel concepts.  And it should be noted that neither honour nor integrity can exist where mutual respect is denied.


When we still valued honour our word was our bond and we sealed a business deal with a hand shake.  But the truth is that honour is held dishonourably when it is contaminated with worldly and self-serving pride.  The risk of living honourably in a dishonourable world has been faced before.  To live honourably in a world where honour is considered negotiable is to lay your hand to the wood as One did so very long ago; yet the Christian is called to recover honour and embrace that high and holy chivalry regardless of the risk.    

Saturday, April 22, 2017

A Night at the Symphony

Beethoven
What was disconcerting about the concert was the conductor, a veritable crow of a man, tall, hunched, his tuxedo tails flapping behind him like great black wings; his every movement fluid and graceful, except for sudden sharp pecking movements with which he called forth the allegro vivace. The piece was well selected for his talents; Beethoven’s Symphony No. 4 in B-flat, Op. 60 with its odd, almost predatory adagio in E-flat major slowly unravelling as the movement progressed until the allegro vivace was introduced.

Two musicians were of peculiar interest, the large, amiable young hedgehog playing the bright red bassoon; and the badger timpanist who played feverishly throughout the piece, and at the very end, following the final glorious rumble of his tympani ate the marshmallows off the end of his drumsticks. Let it be said, after the final bow, several large mice scurried off with the other musicians violins in hand. All in all a very satisfying symphony.

Intermission

Every performance needs an intermission. I used to think the intermission was for the audience, then for a while I thought it was for the performers, but it serves a more mundane purpose, that of moving furniture on stage, or instruments; and a secondary purpose, a mercy bladder break for those who need it. If it weren’t for the necessity of moving furniture, no other urgency would ever stop a performance.
When the furniture is moved, pianos go on or off stage, tympani and percussion instruments are brought forward or retired against a wall, and some of the mice playing violins troop on or off stage and their chairs appropriately appear or disappear.

All of life has its own intermissions but humankind being somewhat short sighted ends up doing one of two things, we either fail to move the necessary emotional furniture on or off stage, or more generally we move too much, too very much on, or most likely, off stage.

Ubi Carrot-tops
It should have been Ubi Caritas, but it wasn’t. Instead it was a cacophony, not a concerto, a piece smashed together mangling that beautiful medieval chant, Ubi caritas et amor, beyond recognition. Before the piece began the soloist played the haunting line of melody from the chant, and that was the only time that the theme was recognizable. The cacophonous tribute bumped and clattered its way through a full sixty minutes or more artfully jammed discordantly into a harsh twenty minutes. The melody was lost and never found. Sometimes love doesn’t conquer all.

The Symphony
Now for the third piece, fatally maligned as “romantic” in the program notes, a piece of glorious music by Robert Schumann, his Symphony No. 4 in D-minor. Op. 120. We didn’t know that this was why we came to the symphony tonight, that this was going to be why tonight’s symphony was actually going to be a symphony, but it was. I am so glad that Robert Schumann, who was according to the program notes a manic/depressive, was not medicated and homogenized by his society, but instead was allowed to have his misery and allowed to have his genius. Today, in our society, we have drugs to make him acceptable and extinguish the nuisance factor that often accompanies genius. That way we can eradicate the romantic element and at the same time glorify the previous unhappy decomposer to enshrine her angst in gems of coprolite.


Instead it was Robert Schumann, who without parroting Ubi caritas, gently and gloriously unfolded for the open hearted the Latin chant, “Ubi caritas et amor, Deus ibi est,” “Where charity and love are, God is there. Christ’s love has gathered us into one. Let us rejoice and be pleased in Him. Let us fear, and let us love the Living God. And may we love each other with a sincere heart.”



Tuesday, April 18, 2017

A Religious Pilgrim Who Wandered from the Path

“Double, double toil and trouble; Fire burn, and caldron bubble.” My step-grandmother was a religous pilgrim. In the old country she was born and baptized Lutheran but there was something about the formal liturgical church that didn't give her that sense of personal power she strove for all her life. She wandered from Lutheranism through Pentacostalism, being re-baptized through the ice; through astrology and fortune telling in a Chicago Tea Room, to the older forms of New Age religion, those cults of American gnosticism that we know of as Unity Truth and Christian Science. At an earlier time in history she would have been feared as a witch. She would have enjoyed being feared.  

We always referred to her as Bestemor, which is the Norwegian word for Grandmother. She and her husband and her daughters immigrated to Canada, and her husband promptly abandoned them and returned to Norway.

The family story was that during the Great Depression she lived in penthouse suites, had male visitors for a living, and put her daughters out in the hall while she pursued her activities. She said of that period of her life, “Built for comfort, not for speed.”

            If she had stayed within the spectrum of Christian religion she would have continued to pursue power and enjoy the fruits of intimidation as she bounced through a variety of denominations, spouting Scripture, invoking the fear of the devil, and claiming special revelation from God in ways that elevated herself and put others down. She would have made an awesome "Church Lady," and would have innoculated many against the discovery of the love of God. But by grace she wandered far afield. 

            If Bestemor were alive and hip today she would be wearing crystals, pentagrams, channeling ancient beings from the spirit world and still intimidating people. She would have delighted in casting curses on political figutes. She loved that stuff because it gave her an illusion of mastery and control over life. But she was a tragic figure and for all her mastery and control was robbed by a stroke that took from her the honey coating charm she wore like a cloak, along with all her recent memories. She muddled through the next thirty years of her life little better than a confused, self-willed, very large child.

            All that journeying is counterfeit Christianity, a mockery of the real power Christians find through surrender to a loving God. Jesus Christ is alive. He can be known through the experience of receiving forgiveness and accepting Him as Saviour. Oh, I know that Bestemor probably mouthed the words. That's probably what her brief sojourn in Pentacostalism was all about. On that rests her only hope of salvation, but she didn't want that kind of power. She wanted control much more than she wanted surrender. 

Mouthing the words isn't good enough. There is a difference between compliance and surrender that she would never have understood. She wanted to leap on the power promises of God. She would have loved controlling the devil by injudicious commands. But true power is closed to those who seek power instead of seeking the love God and dying to themselves. For those who surrender, humble doors open into realms of majesty and joy. His strength, the strength that is made perfect in weakness, becomes reality in lives of the needy for whom alone He came as Ransom. 
                                                                                                            

Monday, April 17, 2017

Movie Review: The Hobbit

The other evening we watched The Desolation of Smaug, the second movie of the Hobbit series directed by Peter Jackson. It had very little to do with the actual book, The Hobbit, by J. R. R. Tolkien, but is a classic example of Hollyweird’s unimaginative rewriting of original classic stories with some attention given to political correctness, you must have female heroines written into the script; and an accompanying romantic Hollyweird interest, this time preposterously between a sylvan female elf and a dwarf. The dwarf had to be tidied up, made taller, and looking like a young handsome man.

Another odd featured was the borrowing of characters from the later Tolkien books, The Lord of the Rings. Mysteriously in the first movie the wizard Saruman the White, and the Lady of Lothlorien appear in Rivendell, from the Lord of the Rings, and now Legolas the elf makes an appearance to increase the romantic tension between the dwarf lady and the dwarf. In addition Jackson adds a White Orc riding a werewolf and his murderous band pursuing the Bilbo and the Dwarves throughout the entire movie and chasing them down as the flee down the river from the elf’s kingdom. Of course that allows for more politically correct additions of the heroic female elf and Legolas as they battle the White Orc.

The wizards Gandalf the Grey and Radagast the Brown [with bird poop in his hair] appear in a castle where Gandalf does battle with the minions of the Necromancer led by the White Orc who puts in another appearance]. At the end we find a lengthy battle between the dwarves and the Dragon Smaug in the bowels of the Lonely Mountain.

The script of the movie adds things that reveal a misunderstanding of the classic story by Tolkien; lots of noise, extended battle scenes, American romantic fantasies, and female heroes. What makes Hollyweird directors like Jackson think they can produce better scripts than they find in classic works of literature?


Monday, April 10, 2017

I am dying that I do not die: St. John of the Cross

This life I live in vital strength
Is loss of life unless I win You:
And thus to die I shall continue
Until in You I live at length.
Listen (my God!) my life is in You.
This life I do not want, for I
Am dying that I do not die.[i]

The theme of dying in order that one may live is central to Contemplative Theology.  Gregory Palamas (14th C) says with clarity that “The Living God is accessible to personal experience, because He shared His own life with humanity.”[ii]  Palamas speaks of this process, of dying in order to live, as a necessary preparation for being transformed into light, even as Christ is Light, “In the affective part of the soul, we bring about the best part by rejecting all that impedes the mind from elevating itself towards God . . . He who has purified his body by temperance, who by divine love has made an occasion of virtue from his wishes and desires, who has presented to God a mind purified by prayer, acquires and sees in himself the grace promised to those whose hearts have been purified.  He can then say with Paul, “God, who has ordered light to shine from darkness, has made His light to shine in our hearts, in order that we may be enlightened by the knowledge of the glory of God, in the face of Jesus Christ”; but he adds, “We carry this treasure in earthen vessels.”  So we carry the Father’s light in the face of Jesus Christ in earthen vessels, that is, in our bodies, in order to know the glory of the Holy Spirit.”[iii]

The practical problem is, “Who wants to die in order to live?”  Every instinct militates against it. Humankind, indeed all of creation, avoids death like the plague that it is; a plague brought about by the Fall.  Adam and Eve’s sin was not eating the apple; it was the sin of preferring their own will instead of accepting the clearly stated Will of God.  The three classic elements of temptation: The lust of the eyes, the lust of the flesh, and the pride of Life; all pander to the desire to have and control life on our terms rather than on God’s.  The result of our preference for our own will in place of God’s will is death.  Far from being “like God, knowing good and evil,” we suffer the natural result of our choices.

In a way, St. John of the Cross, has an advantage.  He is in a narrow prison, beaten, starved, and deprived of even the most elemental necessities, he really has only one clear option, he says, “I am dying that I do not die.”  Make no mistake, we do not want to trade places with St. John of the Cross.  It is no great privilege that he enjoys, but the greatest suffering and privation.

We would much rather have our creature comforts.  We love our sheltering homes, heated and air conditioned.  We have our favourite slippers, and our comfortable clothes, and we even speak of certain foods as “comfort foods.”  At other times, in other cultures, any shelter, heated, or air conditioned, or not, is good; any clothes are good, any food at all is daily bread.  There is great danger in this, our considerable comforts shield us from dying in order that we may live.  Spiritually, we live in a place of greater danger than the Carmelite prison of St. John of the Cross.  Spiritually, we live in the habitation of dragons.”[iv]

There is an old country gospel song that presents us with the choice,

Two coats were before me
An old and a new
I asked my sweet master
Oh what must I do
The old coat was ugly
So tattered and torn
The other a new one
Had never been worn
I'll tell you the best thing
I ever did do
I took off the old coat
And put on the new.

The question remains, just how do we take off the old coat and put on the new?  What comes so easily to mind are the issues of self-discipline, diet, exercise, and the wide variety of entertainments that our society presents to us.  Those things have their importance, but only in reference to the deeper issue; that of the surrender of our will, the surrender of the very thing that was the cause of the Fall at the beginning. 

St. Benedict gives us the key, “To you, therefore, my words are now addressed, whoever you may be, who are renouncing your own will and are taking up the strong, bright armour of obedience to do battle under the Lord Christ, the true King.”[v]  The way of Obedience is the way we walk out of our own wills into the will of the God who made us.  This throws up a tremendous barrier to many within the Church who do not trust the authorities within our hierarchical structures. 

Let me say carefully that there is a hierarchical authority governing all hierarchical authorities.  For us in our Anglican context the basis for authority is first Holy Scripture, and second Tradition, as we find it in the historical Book of Common Prayer.  In the 5th Century, St. Vincent of Lerins put it this way, “we take the greatest care to hold that which has been believed everywhere, always and by all.”[vi]  That is our first, and fundamental obedience.

Given that as the necessary context, we are called to obedience to our bishop, and to those whom God has appointed as our spiritual guides and mentors.   Of this Benedict instructs that, "An Abbot who is worthy to be over a monastery should always remember what he is called, and live up to the name of Superior.  For he is believed to hold the place of Christ in the monastery, being called by a name of his, which is taken from the words of the Apostle: “You have received a Spirit of adoption as sons, by virtue of which we cry, ‘Abba—Father!’”[vii]

The application of this is difficult for those who are essentially Protestant by background and proclivity.  As the Abbot is the father of a monastery so also the parish priest is the father of a flock of God, and is also called by his name (Abba – father).  If the priest is hidden in your Son these are words for him.  The blessed Apostles has said, “Follow me, as I follow Christ!” (I Cor. 11:1).  I can’t think of a sentence in Holy Scripture more terrifying for any priest.  The priest prays with the Psalmist saying, “If your hand is on me, if you make me strong for yourself, then your people will not turn back from you, they will call upon your name.  Restore us, O Lord God of Hosts!  Let your face shine, that we may be saved (Ps. 80:3).  The restoration comes as Your hand rests on the one who is called by your name, Abba. 

It is easy to set black and white rules for obedience, but much more difficult to work out the call to obedience in the context of real life.  While the call to obedience in some things is clear, in many other things we are confronted with considerable ambiguity.  Any decision is apt to be a decision that is essentially an act of faith that we are doing the right thing, and often the failure to act is in itself an act of disobedience.  We tend to think of obedience as primarily a denial of pleasures, when we ought to be thinking of it as the embrace of those responsibilities and challenges that God places before us in the normal course of life.

With St. John of the Cross we pray,

This life I live in vital strength
Is loss of life unless I win You:
And thus to die I shall continue
Until in You I live at length.
Listen (my God!) my life is in You.
This life I do not want, for I
Am dying that I do not die.[viii]







[i] St. John of the Cross, THE POEMS, trans. Roy Campbell, (London: Harvill Press, 1951), p. 55
              Orginal Spanish Verse:
Esta vida que you vivo
Es privación de vivir;
Y así, es continuo morir
Hasta que viva contigo
Oye, mi Dios,  lo que digo,
Que esta vida no la quiero;
Que muero porque no muero.
[ii] Gregory Palamas, The Triads, (New York: Paulist Press, 1983), p.  1
[iii] Ibid, p. 42
[iv] “Thorns shall grow over its stronghold, nettles and thistles in its fortresses.  It shall be a habitation of dragons, a court of owls.  And wild beasts shall meet with the howlers; the satyr shall cry to his fellow; indeed there Lilith settles and finds for herself a resting place” (Isaiah 34:13-14 RPS).
[v] The Rule of St. Benedict, “The Prologue.”
[vi] St. Vincent of Lerins, “The Vincentian Canon,” AD 434, Ancient History Sourcebook.
[vii] The Rule of St. Benedict,
[viii] Ibid, p. 55

Thursday, April 6, 2017

Vision of Christ in a Tortilla Shell

 Web News Item from Several Years Ago: 

  • [See my comments in brackets]

VISION OF CHRIST IN A TORTILLA SHELL
  • [I Kid You Not!]


Maria Orosco, a 78-year-old mother of two, had just finished making herself a homemade tortilla shell when she says she saw the face of Christ materialize in the shell along with three large paragraphs of what appeared to be Hebrew text. Orosco then covered the vision with beans, wrapped it up and ate it. 
  • [“Open your mouth wide and I will fill it.  I am the bread of life. O taste and see that the Lord is good.”]

"I was hungry," Orosco explained to a throng of reporters following the incident. "This is Mexico. Food doesn't exactly grow on trees." 
  • [Good observation, papayas, oranges and bananas not withstanding.]

The world would likely have never known about the vision had not Orosco, overcome with guilt, confessed the whole ordeal to her local priest, Father Jose Colon the next day.
  • [From a pastoral perspective: what is going on here in the area of guilt and grace?]

"I convinced her to go public," Colon told The Holy Observer through an interpreter. "I thought it was important for the world to know that God is still speaking to His children. Why he chose to appear to a ravenously hungry woman as a piece of food—well, that's the first question I'll be asking Him when I get out of purgatory."
  • [Father Colon gets thirty extra days in purgatory (if it exists) for telling the woman to go public!]

The reaction from Biblical scholars around the world has manifested itself in a collective expression of utter disbelief.
  • [Why should we doubt that a poor woman ate a bean burrito?  Blessed art thou holy Maria mother of two, may you always have enough taco shells.]

"We're not talking about some tears on a statue here. This is like if the archaeologists had blown their noses with the Dead Sea Scrolls," said an exasperated Ian Rothchild of the Association of International Bible Scholars. "There's no telling what this message could have been—clarification of the book of Revelation, an answer to predestination versus free will or even a clear message to the Amish to stop living in the past. This woman should be thrown in jail." 

  • [So should ivory tower scholars!]
  • [My personal perception however is that the writing was a list of ingredients, additives, and a calorie, sodium, and carbohydrate count, and that Maria Orosco did exactly what God would have both expected and wanted her to do…she ate the evidence.  In so many of the “relics” of the church someone seems often to have eaten the evidence.  Where are the actual pieces of the true cross?  Where is the ark?  How many fingers did St. Francis have? 12?  The shroud is arguable.  We don’t even have the autographa (originals) of the writings of Holy Scripture… Bloody good thing!  If we did we would worship the pages and invent some vicious Pharisaism and beat people into spiritual submission.]
  • [“Though you have not seen him, you love him.  Though you do not now see him, you believe in him and rejoice with joy unspeakable and full of glory.”  1 Peter 1:8].

Wednesday, April 5, 2017

Cirith Ungol


I do not want to go up the stairs to Cirith Ungol; up those long stairs upon stairs to the tunnel where Shelob awaits upon her thick and sticky web.  Oh, yes, I have read the story a number of times and I know the ending, but even so I must confess that the dividing line between story and reality may occasionally be a little fuzzy.  Don’t mistake my meaning.  On an intellectual level I clearly discern the difference between fantasy and reality, but on an emotional level it may be quite another thing. 

Ever since I was a child I was not just a reader.  A mere reader is such a poor and paltry creature.  No.  I jump right into a story both feet first.  In my childhood summers I fought in the American Revolution with Johnny Tremain, sailed with Mr. Christian on the Bounty, traversed the southern seas on the raft Kon Tiki with Thor Heyerdahl, and ran away with Huckleberry Finn and Jim down the wide Mississippi.  To me good books, good stories, grow richer with every reading; but shallow books are briskly read and just as quickly traded at Half Price Books.

Tonight while I do not want to go up the stairs to Cirith Ungol with Frodo and Samwise, I also remember the wisdom of Sam’s father, the Gaffer, who said, “Where there’s life there’s hope, … and need of vittles.”  I know that there is an end to the tunnel with its horror.  There’s always an end to tunnels.  I have seen Shelob, grievously wounded by Sting, retreat gibbering leaving a trail of green ooze upon the path.  I have seen Sam rescue Frodo from captivity in the guard tower upon Cirith Ungol and I know that they are going to come out alright in the end.

Yet still I do not want to go up the hill to Cirith Ungol, not tonight.  Perhaps tomorrow in the clear light of day I will climb that long and dangerous path to the Spider’s Cleft where Shelob waits with evil malice.  Light more powerful than the Phial of Galadriel, Light of Christ preserve me, preserve us all in our waking and our sleeping dreams.

I have trod the weary steps up to Cirith Ungol once before, nay, many times before with nameless dread pursuing me; but at the end no evil land of Mordor, but rather the first step on heaven’s table land, a golden platform in the sky, eight sides upon that platform wide, each side equal of golden lattice filigreed, and overarching all tranquillité d’esprit.1  He gives peace to those who climb and conquer fear.


1. Tranquility of the spirit and the mind.

The Blueberry Seller

The Blueberry Seller

Route 1 hugs much of the shore line along the south east coast of Maine. Here and there small harbour towns are interspersed with stretches of wild woods. Here you will see the aspen, the birch, the red maples and the sugar maples, several types of oaks, the white and red pines, the spruces, balsam fir and others.

It was on one such stretch where the woods crowded close to edge of the road that I began to notice people selling something out of the trunks of cars and the back of pickup trucks. At last I saw a sign. “Bluberrys” it said. I slowed down and pulled over by a weathered beaten old Ford pickup and I got out to take a look.

The berry seller was a stocky individual about my height, perhaps a little taller, but there was something odd, almost menacing about him. He snorted almost like tuning up his voice and addressed me in a growly sort of voice, “Berries?” His little brown eyes narrowed with the apparent intensity of attempted thought.

“How much” I asked?

“Three dollars a pint, five dollars, two pints,” he growled.

The berry seller was immense, at least 400 pounds or more. Black hair sprouted profusely from the neck of his t-shirt. One very hairy arm sported a new tattoo, the smiling image of Smokey the Bear. The arm looked like it had been shaved in order to accommodate the tattoo.

I produced a five dollar bill and he motioned towards the back of the pickup, “Which pints you want?” The berry seller was apparently friendly, even affable, but thoroughly alarming. He looked very much like a bear, he sounded like a bear would if a bear could talk, he smelled like a bear. His feet were stuffed into big black rubber boots, his hands were clad in heavy duty work gloves. His face was clean shaven, but perhaps that isn’t really a good description. His shaving job was a little rough and patchy and left much to be desired. His nose was large, flat, and almost looked like black that had been powdered with mild yellow pollen.

I looked at the tiny blueberries, at least most of them were blue, but scattered among them was a liberal quantity of small leaves, green berries, and broken stems. Stupidly I asked, “Are they washed?”

His large face momentarily glazed over with apparent guilt, or was it just discomfort? “They ain’t got bug sprays on ‘em. Don’t wash ‘em until just before you eat ‘em, they go mouldy. Then he smiled, his honest face reflecting a simple sincerity, almost a yearning to be believed and accepted.

Hurriedly I picked out two pints and he shoved them into a small plastic grocery bag and passed them to me. As we moved slowly away I looked in the rearview mirror. He had taken the glove off of one very hairy hand with long black nails, pulled up his t-shirt to reveal the dense black hair on his belly and was unconcernedly scratching himself.