Monday, May 15, 2017

Lincoln and Lee on the Terrible Nature of War





  Among the treasures at the Gilcrease Museum in Tulsa is a small but significant collection of memorabilia from the period of the American Civil War that is tucked in among a marvellous selection of Fredrick Remington bronzes and paintings by Charles Russell and Thomas Moran.  Two exhibits side by side are quite striking; one the life mask and hands of Abraham Lincoln, the other a picture of Robert E. Lee accompanied by the following quote from a letter from Lee in 1861 to his sister:

“With all my devotion to the Union and the feeling of loyalty and duty of an American citizen, I have not been able to make up my mind to raise my hands against my relatives, my children, my home.  I have therefore resigned my commission in the Amy, and save in defense of my native state, with the sincere hope that my poor services may never need be needed, I hope I may never be called on to draw my sword. . . “

One of the tragedies of the American Civil War is that it pitted Christian against Christian in one of the most savage conflicts in our history.   Despite Lee’s sincere hope he was inevitably drawn into the conflict, and but for his skill and determination as a military leader the war would likely have been considerably shorter.  The time would come when General Ambrose Burnside would stolidly and stupidly send his Union troops in a feckless assault of the Confederate positions on the heights above Fredericksburg.  On December 13th, 1862 Lee made the following remark, “It is well that war is so terrible - otherwise we would grow too fond of it.” 

Lee’s fierce right hand man Stonewall Jackson was a man of ardent faith, and fearless disposition.  Of his sense of security in battle Jackson said, "My religious belief teaches me to feel as safe in battle as in bed.”  Whether or not one agrees with Lee and Jackson, or with Lincoln and Union Leaders like Joshua Chamberlain their faith should be taken seriously.

On the opposite wall at the Gilcrease is a quote from Lincoln at the Philadelphia Sanitary Fair in June of 1864.  A Sanitary Fair raised funds for the medical and practical care of soldiers by auctioning art, curios and memorabilia.  In his speech Lincoln said,

“War at its best, is terrible, and this war of ours, In its magnitude and in its duration is one of the most terrible . . . it has carried mourning to almost every home, until it can almost be said that the ‘heavens are hung in black.’ Yet the war is continues.”

            Individual Christians from time to time find themselves in opposition to each other, but that is the nature of the fallen world in which we live.  Only the very naïve would make the mistake of thinking that the conflicts of the past, of either the American Civil War, or of the past of each person can be fairly evaluated by hind sight.  In the midst of the conflicts of life it is not always so easy.  There is perhaps even a reason for war, as God’s way of teaching his hard hearted people the ways of faith.


Now these are the nations that the LORD left, to test Israel by them, that is, all in Israel who had not experienced all the wars in Canaan.  It was only in order that the generations of the people of Israel might know war, to teach war to those who had not known it before” [Judges 3:1].

Friday, May 5, 2017

Sir Mallow de Mar

Editor’s Note:


The following is one of the lost tales from the recently discovered “Le Déjeuner d’Arthur.” This tale, like “The Quest of Sir Cochon Le Cur Faible” is part of a larger cycle of tales about aspiring knights seeking to join the Knights of the Round Table. Le Déjeuner was originally a collection of oral stories recorded by an unknown French printer that some have identified as Jean Dupré, a contemporary of Caxton whose edition of Le Morte d’Arthur is well known to English readers. Through historical misadventure an early copy of Le Déjeuner was taken by Louis-Joseph de Montcalm to New France where it was eventually translated into Quebecois. Unfortunately the French original was lost, and only the Quebecois version remains today. For those of you unfamiliar with Quebecois as a “language”, Quebecois is to French as Spanglish is to English. Tonton Guillaume Cloche has given us this current translation of Le Déjeuner. Today the only known copy of the work can be found in the Royal Canadian Museum of History in Toronto.


It was early in the season of Pentecost when one came riding to Arthur’s court out of the eastern shires. His colours per bend sinister upon his shield were rich chocolate brown and the purest white. He was a hefty knight and full of hearty cheer at finding a new court and a new lord. The court from which he fled was grown stale and its lord right pale, no leader of worthy knights, a narrow poxy man that by Sir Mallow de Mar’s own account honoured not such knights as bold brave Sir Mallow de Mar.

“My liege lord King Arthur,” says Sir Mallow de Mar, “right glad I am to come to the aid of such a worthy king as thou. Command me, Lord. I am your humble servant, and I will gladly lead any quest and work any work that you desire.”

Right glad was Arthur to hear the bold yet humble words of such a mighty knight. But Merlin stood afar off, watchful, pondering, and Sir Gawain with a thin lipped smile beat softly upon his shield with clenched fist.

One reason why King Arthur was such a noble well loved king was that his heart was open, and glad was he to give right good welcome to those who came in good faith; yet Arthur’s weakness was that always there were some who came for other reasons. No good will come from those who offer themselves to a new king when they harbour evil in their hearts for the liege lord they leave behind. Their compliments are a sweet poison that will soon turn sour. Soon Arthur would be beating upon his own shield with a closed fist.

As Sir Mallow de Mar spoke on with silvered words of praise Arthur suddenly became aware of the soft thud of Gawain’s clenched fist beating upon his shield; then looked from the face of Gawain to that of Merlin. Merlin stood with arms folded across his chest, his eyes fixed on Arthur. Arthur continued to smile, but took a step backward away from Sir Mallow de Mar who eagerly pressed forward.

At last Arthur spoke, “There are but two empty seats at the Table Round. One has been prophesied of old. The other may be filled only by one who has won worship through a noble quest. Welcome good guest, but abide and wait for a worthy quest to arise.”

The word’s were neither approval or rejection, just words of courtesy, and though Sir Mallow de Mar answered Arthur’s smile with a smile of his own, his eyes belied his smile and his fair words. Soon he would mount his palfrey and move on seeking entrance at the court of some more worthy king, and complaining all the while of the inhospitable nature of King Arthur who failed to recognize the great gifts Sir Mallow de Mar had offered to the Table Round.