Monday, April 17, 2017

Movie Review: The Hobbit

The other evening we watched The Desolation of Smaug, the second movie of the Hobbit series directed by Peter Jackson. It had very little to do with the actual book, The Hobbit, by J. R. R. Tolkien, but is a classic example of Hollyweird’s unimaginative rewriting of original classic stories with some attention given to political correctness, you must have female heroines written into the script; and an accompanying romantic Hollyweird interest, this time preposterously between a sylvan female elf and a dwarf. The dwarf had to be tidied up, made taller, and looking like a young handsome man.

Another odd featured was the borrowing of characters from the later Tolkien books, The Lord of the Rings. Mysteriously in the first movie the wizard Saruman the White, and the Lady of Lothlorien appear in Rivendell, from the Lord of the Rings, and now Legolas the elf makes an appearance to increase the romantic tension between the dwarf lady and the dwarf. In addition Jackson adds a White Orc riding a werewolf and his murderous band pursuing the Bilbo and the Dwarves throughout the entire movie and chasing them down as the flee down the river from the elf’s kingdom. Of course that allows for more politically correct additions of the heroic female elf and Legolas as they battle the White Orc.

The wizards Gandalf the Grey and Radagast the Brown [with bird poop in his hair] appear in a castle where Gandalf does battle with the minions of the Necromancer led by the White Orc who puts in another appearance]. At the end we find a lengthy battle between the dwarves and the Dragon Smaug in the bowels of the Lonely Mountain.

The script of the movie adds things that reveal a misunderstanding of the classic story by Tolkien; lots of noise, extended battle scenes, American romantic fantasies, and female heroes. What makes Hollyweird directors like Jackson think they can produce better scripts than they find in classic works of literature?


No comments:

Post a Comment